Katie Holmes Welcomed Fall in a Cozy Sweater Style She’s Worn Before — Get the Look from $26

If anyone can make a case for outfit-repeating, it’s Katie Holmes.

The actress ushered in sweater weather wearing not just a classic pattern, but a style she’s reached for before. She stepped out in New York in a cozy Fair Isle sweater with a gray background and colorful cream-and-red pattern across the chest and upper arms. She teamed it with light blue barrel-leg jeans, a slouchy leather duffel, brown suede belt, and leather ballet flats.

Holmes is no stranger to wearing Fair Isle sweaters; she snuggled up in a similar knit style back in 2022. And she’s not the only celeb to layer up in Fair Isle once the temperatures drop, either. Jennifer Lopez wore a cashmere Ralph Lauren version when seeing The Music Man in New York a couple years ago, and Kate Middleton announced royal holiday plans in 2023 wearing a Fair Isle turtleneck.

Fair Isle sweaters are a wardrobe essential that will easily take you through the colder months in style. Wear them with wide-leg jeans like Holmes, a mini skirt and tights, corduroy trousers, or even layered over a dress.

Ready to try out the preppy-meets-sophisticated trend like Holmes? Shop similar Fair Isle sweaters on Amazon starting at $26.

Fair Isle Sweaters Inspired by Katie Holmes

• Velvet Makenzie Sweater, $116 (orig. $257)
• Nautica Sustainably Crafted Mock-Neck Fair Isle Sweater, $37
• Dokotoo Fair Isle Cardigan, $27 with coupon (orig. $38)
• Amazon Essentials Soft-Touch Fair Isle Sweater, $34 (orig. $36)
• Yemocile Fair Isle Sweater, $31
• Chouyatou Fair Isle Crewneck Pullover, $26
• The Drop Valeria Fair Isle Sweater, $46
• Cable Stitch Fair Isle Sweater, $40
• Lookbookstore Knit Pullover, $40 (orig. $46)

Velvet Makenzie Sweater

This sweater is designed in a soft blend of wool, alpaca, and other fibers, with a bold Fair Isle pattern across the front and down the sleeves. It’s finished with a crew neckline and wide ribbing at the cuffs and hem.

Nautica Sustainably Crafted Mock-Neck Fair Isle Sweater

A sweeping Fair Isle design accents this soft sweater’s mock-neck collar and subtle lantern sleeves. One happy shopper called the pattern “delightful” and added that the sweater is not only “comfortable,” but “washes great.”

Dokotoo Fair Isle Cardigan

Try out the pattern of the season in a fitted cardigan with four buttons down the front and ribbing at the cuffs and hem. It comes in six colors, including beige, green, and orange, and sizes S–XXL.

Amazon Essentials Soft-Touch Fair Isle Sweater

Inspired by the cream-colored Fair Isle sweater Holmes wore a couple years back, this crewneck version has a colorful pattern across the neckline and subtly fitted silhouette. The sweater has racked up over 1,400 perfect ratings; one satisfied reviewer said it’s “very flattering and looks just like the picture,” adding that it’s “warm and soft.”

Yemocile Knitted Fair Isle Sweater

Choose a Fair Isle sweater similar to Holmes’ gray version with this cozy knit that also has the colorful design at the cuffs. Shoppers said it’s “very nice quality” and “super soft.”

Chouyatou Fair Isle Crewneck Pullover

This Fair Isle sweater comes in off-white with an orange-based pattern or charcoal gray with a pink-and-blue one. It’s finished with ribbed trim at the neckline, cuffs, and hem, and it’s available in sizes XS–XXL.

The Drop Valeria Fair Isle Sweater

Embrace the Fair Isle trend with this sweater that features the pattern from top to bottom. It comes in two colors and sizes XXS–5X, and it’s finished with contrast ribbing at the crew neckline, cuffs, and hem.

Cable Stitch Fair Isle Sweater

A jacquard Fair Isle pattern at the neckline and cuffs lends this cotton sweater timeless appeal; choose from five colors and sizes XS–XL. “I get a lot of compliments when I wear it,” raved one shopper, continuing that it’s “a good weight for winter and can be dressed up or down.”

Lookbookstore Knit Pullover

With 11 takes on classic Fair Isle to choose from, including snowflakes and reindeer, this sweater is sure to put a smile on your face every time you wear it. “I was pleasantly surprised at how well-made this sweater is,” one shopper said, adding that it’s “comfortable, not scratchy, and warm.”